Pirate Crybabies
Friday, October 28th, 2005The first trials against pirates sharing movies using directconnect and similar tools have just ended here in Sweden with the acused being sentenced to fines. As expected, this provoced a new wave of whining on how horrible the system of intellectual property is and that piracy should be legalized. Not only are these crybabies making a fool of themselves demanding unrealistic benefits for themselves while offering no solutions whatsoever, they always fail to see the real issues underlying this. Instead of trying to find solutions for micropayments or sustainable licensing schemes for immaterial distribution, they whine about how they should have more rights to the content being produced than the author. Now thats an intelligent suggestions, five points for stupidity. So lets take a small analytic look at their main argument.
Piracy should be legal :: The only way piracy can be legal is if we refuse to credit content (read: intellectual property) with neither value nor rights. In a situation like that piracy wouldn’t exist since an item without rights or value can be copied without anyone claiming any loss. This does in fact exists today already, vast amounts of data is generated without value or rightful owner, such as noise or electrical interference. The following implication is that in a world like this, neither need nor interest to copy anything exist since no value is accredited. This since an easy rule of thumb is that if anyone wants to explore the content, it has a value if only for one person. So for piracy to be legal, we need to lose all interest content and only regard raw data as a placeholder. This also justifies their second claim that digital piracy doesnt cost the businisses anything since they didnt spend anything making the copy, which in other words also means that since content is worthless, these brainies might as well buy blank CDRs and pop in their stereos.
In other words: quit bloody whining, grow up and smell the coffee for after all, it’s your own fault!. This discussion exists due to the system of economic democracy (capitalism) that we all agree on being The Right Thing, so learn the rules of the game or vote for an alternative solution at the next election. There is no such thing as a free lunch.